The 3 Operational Steps to Innovation That Delivers Defensible Profit

Why Your Innovation Strategy is Failing (and How to Fix It)

If you are an SME leader, you already know the painful truth: innovation feels like a luxury. You don’t have the time or the budget for abstract concepts like “brand equity”. Every resource committed to a new idea is a financial risk that could cripple your core business.

The challenge is simple: How do you pursue the necessary future growth (Exploration) without draining the resources of your current, profitable business (Exploitation)?

The solution is to ditch the sporadic pursuit of “brilliant ideas” and adopt a rigorous, operational framework.

We call this framework the 3 Operational Steps for Innovation in SMEs—a direct workflow to ensure your projects are useful, profitable, and defensible.

The NorthStar Operational Mandate: 3 Steps to Defensible Profit

Innovation for an SME must be a financially sound mandate, not a vague goal. Before any resource is committed, your strategy must provide clear answers to these three essential questions.

Step 1: Define the Mandate (The “If”)

Can We Do It Efficiently?

The starting point isn’t novelty—it’s efficiency and costs.

• The Focus: What is the precise purpose of this project, and how will it demonstrably optimise operations and cut costs?
• The Filter: Innovation must translate directly into operational gains, such as decreasing operational costs, accelerating order fulfilment, or increasing output.
• The Decision: If the project cannot clearly demonstrate long-term cost reduction and operational optimisation, it must be re-evaluated.

Key Concept: This step anchors your project in Technological Capacity (TC), the internal ability to optimise existing systems to strengthen your core business.

Step 2: Value Creation Through Innovation (The “How”)

Can We Profit and Defend It? 

Once you’ve confirmed internal efficiency, the focus shifts to external market success.

• The Focus: What specific, unique value will this innovation deliver to the customer (convenience, performance, lower price) that your competitors cannot immediately match?
• The Goal: The value generated must be unique and protected. For an SME, this means leveraging your distinctive assets—like deep niche knowledge, hyper-local reputation, or customer proximity—to create a “right to win” that a global competitor cannot replicate.

Key Concept: This is the core of Value Creation and Value Capture. You are defining the Blue Ocean Strategy (BOS)—an uncontested market space—by solving a specific, frustrating ‘job to be done’ that existing solutions fail to address.

Step 3: Maintaining Value and Setting Industry Standards (The “What”)

Confirm Defence Mechanisms

An amazing idea is useless if it can be copied next week. The final step is essential for long-term profit.

• The Focus: What specific barriers to entry (legal, operational, or asset-based) will protect your profitability and sustain your competitive advantage?
• The Defence: You must leverage unique assets, such as exclusive agreements, long-term supply agreements, or legal protection (e.g., TM/patents), to create a structural advantage rivals cannot match.
• The Decision: If unique assets or legal protection cannot be leveraged, the long-term investment must be re-evaluated.

The Biggest Risk is Doing Nothing

If you face scepticism about investing in Exploration, translate the challenge into a simple cash flow argument: You must spend a small, protected fraction of today’s profit (Exploitation) to secure tomorrow’s revenue stream (Exploration).

This process—moving through Define, Create, and Maintain—is how you ensure every innovation project is rigorously screened for strategic fit, internal capability, and external risk before significant capital is committed.

The full framework, which includes the Three Horizons Model for resource allocation, the NorthStar Ambidextrous Check (TM) filter, is what allows you to transform innovation from a high-risk bet into a coherent, sustainable engine for growth.

Stop Guessing. Get the Blueprint.

We have created a comprehensive course tailored for SMEs to start innovation with profitability in mind.

👉 Enrol in Microcourse 1: “Introduction to Innovation for SMEs” for only £89 and master the operational steps to defensible profit.